Atlas Shrugged Quick ReviewSo I saw Atlas Shrugged with my wife last night, and I had a few quick thoughts. First was that I was surprised how emotional seeing it on screen made me, especially the opening scenes. They do a great job of capturing the essence of the book. The actress who plays Dagny was superb, and really held the movie together. And while the movie had it’s issues, it isn’t nearly as bad as some Objectivist quarters would have you believe. I did have a few specific issues with the movie however. The movie was only an hour and a half long, which makes some of the editorial decisions questionable. They left out Francisco’s money is the root of all evil speech, which seems puzzling. They totally screwed up the bracelet exchange with Dagny and Lillian. And the Hugh Akston character is all wrong. And they went with these dossier like breaks in the film whenever an executive disappears. And finally, the guy reading the lines for John Galt was terrible. In total, while I enjoyed the film, I do have to wonder about the ability of someone unfamiliar with the book to follow everything in the movie. In any event, I should hope that enough people see it to be able to finance the remainder of the trilogy. At the theater I went to, it was about 3/4 filled. All told I’d recommend the movie and would encourage you to go see it. Tags: Atlas Shrugged |
||

One Response to “Atlas Shrugged Quick Review”
April 18th, 2011 at 10:03 am
Pretty much my review! Which is half-written and emphasizes the Hugh Akston part. Later I thought in some ways it’s like a series of scenes and dialog directly from the book, connected adequately overall by film-oriented Reader’s Digest bridges that convey enough of the basic story to hold it together. The “bad parts,” then, come to any spots the bridges aren’t quite adequate and/or what is left out. I might hope for a director’s cut on DVD that covers some of that. Sadly… I forgot the money speech was missing!
Leave a Reply